One of my quiet devotions in the food world is Shaker cooking. I grew up near, and sometimes in, the city of Shaker Heights, Ohio, an early twentieth-century “streetar suburb” of Cleveland where at one point there had been a substantial Shaker presence. The Shakers were, of course, long gone by the time there were streetcars: their community, which was called the North Union Settlement or, by some, The Valley of God’s Pleasures (and isn’t that a fantastic monicker?) reached its peak in the mid-19th century and had faded into near obscurity by the time the Shakers sold their land to the Van Sweringen brothers who went on to establish it as a town.
But I do digress. The point is, I grew up in an area that had a Shaker history, and a number of Shaker recipes had made their way into the local culinary vernacular. Since then I have, as they’ve come my way, collected Shaker recipes, which I have found to be as trustworthy as Shaker carpentry and created in much the same spirit: Shaker food is not fancy, in fact it is quite plain, but it is very sturdy and beautiful.
In keeping with the Shaker spirit of economy and resource management, Shaker cooking is also thrifty and geared toward making much of little. Certainly we can all, particularly in straitened times, do with more of that.
Best of all, these pies are very simple to produce, and, as the Shakers well knew, simplicity is a gift. Pies like these are easy enough, and good enough, to make you wonder why you would ever buy a pie.
In that spirit, I offer you my two favorite Shaker pie recipes. Both are winter pies, not summer pies, although I suppose you could make them in summer if you wanted. They have the additional attraction of being non-dairy, and the cranberry-raisin is vegan so long as you eat some form of granulated sugar. I will presume for the sake of argument when presenting these that you already have a pie crust recipe in hand and know what to do with it.
Shaker Cranberry-Raisin Pie
crust for double-crust 9 inch pie
1 to 1.5 cups fresh raw whole cranberries, washed and stemmed
one-half to 1 cup seedless raisins (you may substitute dried sweet cherries, dried blueberries, or other small sweet dried fruit if you prefer)
3/4 cup sugar
pinch salt
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1 Tablespoon all-purpose flour
Preheat oven to 350F. Line pie dish with bottom crust.
In a bowl mix fruit, dried fruit, sugar, salt, vanilla, and flour with a fork. The variable amounts of cranberries to dried fruit allow you to adjust the sweetness of the finished pie. If you use equal amounts of cranberries and dried fruit, you can expect a quite sweet pie, for the dried fruit is there partly to act as a sweetener. If you increase the cranberries and decrease the dried fruit it will be more tart.
Pour fruit mixture into prepared pie crust, dispersing sugar evenly, and top with second crust. Cut several slits (make them decorative if you like) into the top crust so that steam can escape. Bake at 350F until evenly browned on top and allow to cool completely before cutting.
Note: Cranberries should be plump, smooth, and very hard. Discard any cranberries that are wrinkled, wet, soft, or seem badly bruised.
The Cranberry-Raisin pie is a homey pie, comforting and surprisingly rich-tasting. Serve it in narrow slices. It is very nice with ice cream, and also with tart homemade applesauce.
By contrast, the lemon pie for which I am about to give the recipe is a showstopper. No one expects a pie made of whole lemons. Certainly no one expects it to taste as amazing as it does. Because of the presence of the lemon rind and pith, it has a wonderful marmalade-like taste, a symphonic combination of sweet, sour, and bitter. If you make it with a double crust, it is all the more unexpected since typically both lemon pies and custard pies (of which this is a variant) are single-crust pies. I prefer it as a double-crust pie, as I feel the extra crust helps balance out the intensity of the filling, but your tastes may well be different. Do what you feel tastes best.
Shaker Lemon Pie
pie crust for either a single or double-crust 9″ pie
2 lemons, well scrubbed (organic by preference if you can get them)
2 cups sugar
1 teaspoon salt
4 large eggs
4 Tablespoons flour
1 teaspoon vanilla extract (optional)
The Day Before:
Blanch lemons in boiling water for 2 minutes. Cool in a pan of cold water. Slice paper-thin, rind and all, with a sharp knife or, if you have one, a mandoline of some sort, I suppose, although you’d never have caught a Shaker cook with one. Truly, though, you want to slice the lemon as thinly as you possibly can manage; the thicker the slices the more likely you are to end up with objectionably bitter bits in your pie because the sugar won’t be able to penetrate the rinds properly. Remove the pips as you go.
Combine the lemon slices in a bowl with the salt and sugar. Mix well to combine, cover, and set aside in the refrigerator for 24 hours.
Assembling The Pie:
Preheat oven to 425F.
Line the pie dish with bottom crust.
In a bowl, whisk together the eggs and flour (and vanilla if using) until smooth. Add sugar/lemon mixture and mix in carefully with a spatula or wooden spoon until thoroughly combined. Pour into the bottom crust and gently pat down any protruding lemon slices. Try to make sure the lemons are more or less evenly distributed throughout the pie.
Add top crust, if using.
Bake for the first 20 minutes at 425F, then reduce heat to 350F and continue baking until pie is well set in the center (test by jiggling the dish — if the center doesn’t shimmy, you’re good to go).
Cool completely before cutting, as the filling finishes setting during the cooling process. Cutting prematurely will result in filling oozing all over the place like lemon magma, which may or may not appeal to you. It does not really appeal to me, but some of you people are weird.
Serve the lemon pie with tea, it is a natural pairing. A little plain unsweetened whipped cream on the pie would not go amiss if you are the type to bother with such a thing, but if not, don’t worry about it.
Both pies keep well. Because the lemon pie is not a true custard, it does not tend to weep and cannot separate, so if you normally avoid making eggy pies because you suffer from Custard Fear, try this one.