For cream-style soups, don’t just dump in soy milk willy-nilly. The texture suffers. A better bet is to use soymilk that’s diluted by about half with broth, and thicken as desired either with a roux, or with breadcrumbs, a handful of rice, or some peeled potato — with these last three, just simmer until the starch disintegrates.
For casseroles, the vegan cream-style soup-in-a-boxes are not bad for the most part. I’m not always keen on the soups as soups, but if you want a nondairy tuna noodle hotdish, vegan cream of mushroom soup is totally the way to go.
You can approximate a “cheese sauce” without dairy by making a “roux” of margarine or oil and nutritional yeast, then adding (unsweetened, unflavored!) soy milk or other milk substitute until it is the thickness you want. Season with mustard, nutmeg, sauteed or roasted garlic, caramelized onions, black pepper, etc. It’s not cheese, but it’s not bad, and you can get pretty close to a mac and cheese mouthfeel with it if you tinker around some. It’s a good thing to have in your hip pocket for those times when comfort food is not optional.
Nutritional yeast is also your answer to cheese-flavored snack foods: mix about a half cup of nutritional yeast with a couple tablespoons of garlic powder and onion powder, some sweet paprika, some ground Aleppo pepper if you like a little heat, a little ground celery seed, and salt to taste. Sprinkle over popcorn or roasted cauliflower or whatever else you like. It’s an outstanding popcorn topping and may help you forget cheesey poofs and Smartfood.
News Flash: The Creamy Salad Dressing of your Dreams Has Always Been Dairy-Free. Hollyhock Dressing is made as follows… 1 cup olive oil + 1/3 cup water + 1/3 cup cider vinegar or balsamic vinegar + 1/3 cup regular soy sauce + 1 cup nutritional yeast + whiz in blender until creamy and smooth = OMGdelicious. Up the ante by adding as much fresh raw or roasted garlic as you think you might enjoy. Me, I will often use an entire bulb of garlic for a batch of this stuff, but of course it depends on how hot the garlic is. This dressing is also outrageously good with potatoes, and other veggies, especially roasted ones. And it’s orgasmic with fresh tomatoes.
Pizza is still good without cheese. Adding lots of high-flavor ingredients, like chopped pickled peppers, anchovies (if you eat fish), olives, onions, roasted garlic, and the like makes it work even better. My favorite pizza, made by my local Egyptian pizzeria, is called the Dahb, and consists of their chewy, wheaty, out-of-this-world crust topped with roasted marinated eggplant slices, chopped red slightly hot pickled peppers, black olives, sliced garlic, and chopped sun-dried tomatoes. It’s toe-curlingly good.
In Italy, cheese is not sprinkled over every damn pasta dish in the world like we tend to do here. My advice is to make sure your sauce stands on its own, buy or make really good fresh pasta, and enjoy it like they do in the old country. We’re almost at pasta puttanesca season…
Pesto without cheese is fantastic. I make it with pecans, basil, garlic, oil, and salt, and it’s divine. Also, you can make other pestos. Pesto di noci — walnuts, parsley, marjoram, garlic — is trad Ligurian voluptuousness and well worth your time.
Oh, and even though I probably didn’t need to mention it: most Southeast Asian cuisines don’t cook with milk, traditionally. There are occasional exceptions, but for the most part, you can eat your way through Chinese (esp. southern), Japanese, Thai, Malay, Cambodian, Myanmarese, Vietnamese, Hmong, Laotian, Indonesian, and other cuisines of the region without a hitch. The dairy tends to come in when you get into the steppes and herding territory: Nepal, Tibet, Mongolia, Bhutan.
Indian food is tricky; Indian food that is not Traditional Indian Restaurant Outside Of India menu food is easier and there are vastly more options if you cook it yourself than if you’re depending on a restaurant to do it for you. Do note that tofu will sub for paneer in most applications, and that coconut milk will do nicely for dairy milk in many cases. Southern Indian coconut milk payasam — a near relative of the rice pudding called kheer — will make you very happy indeed.